Welcome to Michael's New York Style Pizza
In the heart of Paducah, KY, Michael's New York Style Pizza offers a classy dining experience with a range of delicious options. From mouthwatering appetizers like fried mushrooms and crazy stix to hearty pasta dishes like baked spaghetti and lasagna, there is something for everyone to enjoy. With a variety of salads and a cozy outdoor seating area, this restaurant is not only wheelchair accessible but also perfect for groups and kids. Whether you're dining in or ordering delivery, Michael's New York Style Pizza is a must-visit for a taste of authentic New York-style pizza and more.
-
901 Kentucky Ave Paducah, KY 42003 Hotline: (270) 443-0300
Welcome to Michael's New York Style Pizza, a gem located in Paducah, KY, known for serving up some of the best pizza in town. With a wide array of menu options, including appetizers like Fried Mushrooms and Crazy Stix, salads, pasta dishes like Baked Spaghetti and Lasagna, and of course, their famous New York style pizza, there is something for everyone to enjoy.
Customers rave about the quality and authenticity of the pizza at Michael's. Reviewers like Dale S. and Curtis M. note that the crust is reminiscent of what you'd find in New York City, making it a standout choice for pizza lovers. The lunch special, which includes two slices of pizza, is a popular choice among patrons like Matthew B. who can't get enough of the fast service and good quality.
One customer, Rhyah F., even travels from southeast Missouri just to indulge in Michael's pizza, citing its old-school feel and delicious flavor as major draws. And for those looking for a taste of authenticity, Jeremy E. praises the fresh ingredients, great crust, and traditional approach to pizza-making at Michael's.
Overall, the consensus among customers is clear - Michael's New York Style Pizza is a must-visit for anyone craving a taste of the Big Apple right here in Paducah. With its friendly service, authentic flavors, and dedication to quality, this pizzeria is sure to become a favorite among pizza enthusiasts.
Old fashioned pizza place. Chicken wings have some great sauce. Single pizza slices not served after lunch but the 4-piece small pizza was perfect. Everyone super friendly.
Excellent pizza and service. The lunch special with two slices of pizza is perfect, and the crust is exactly like pizza crust I've had in New York. Some of the best I've ever had.
Best pizza in town in my opinion, especially if you like thin New York style. They are typically always busy during lunch hours in the restaurant, but we typically get take out or delivery.
Best pizza in Paducah! Fast service and good quality! If I worked closer to that side I'd be a daily
Went here on a recommendation and was not disappointed. The place is a throwback style pizzeria but served up some good pizza. Ordered the pepperoni and sausage combo pizza because the other pictures looked good. Service takes a little long but that is because the place is busy and serves great food. Definitely will order here again.
We travel from southeast Missouri to Paducah just for this pizza. It reminds me of an 80s movie pizza place with its old school feel. We just like it all.
Traveling through on business and wanting some "good"pizza. Looked on Yelp and found in Michael's New York Style Pizza. Called theses guys up for a delivery, they gave me the run down and the order was placed. Pie showed up about 20+ minutes later and I got to say. Great Job Y'all! Great Crust/Sauce, fresh veggies and meats. Nothing fancy (and I mean that in a good way) just great pizza. Some people just try to hard to be different, thinking that will get them business. That may work for a minute, but it want last. If supported by the local community, Michael's Nee York Style Pizza will be around forever. These guys made a plan, and are sticking to it. Really great pie guys! Jeremy
The pizza was delicious. The crust was incredible. The service was a+. The only reason it got a 4 was the condition of the women's room. It smelled like it could use a real deep cleaning.
We read the reviews and decided to stop. It was so good! We got the crazy sticks, extra marinara, and a large supreme. The crust is so different than any pizza we normally eat. So crunchy on the bottom and so light it almost disappears when you eat it. Never been to NY, but it's definitely not like Chicago or Quad City style. It was a welcome change. Everyone in here is so friendly!! Definitely worth a stop!!
Michael's is my favorite pizza place! Truly authentic Italian pizza. My sister has moved away from the area and this is her first request as soon as she comes in town. SO GOOD!