Michael's New York Style Pizza Menu (Update 2025)

Introducing Michael's New York Style Pizza, a classic pizzeria in Paducah, KY, known for its authentic New York-style pizza. From crispy thin crust to savory toppings, this spot has garnered rave reviews from customers near and far. The menu features tempting appetizers like Fried Mushrooms and Crazy Stix, along with hearty salads and pasta dishes.

Customers praise the impeccable service and the quality of the pizza, with many noting the resemblance to New York slices. The lunch special, featuring two slices of pizza, is a crowd favorite. The cozy, old-school atmosphere adds to the charm of dining at Michael's. Whether you're a local or passing through, this pizzeria promises a slice of pure pizza bliss.

Appetizers

Fried Mushrooms

$5.99

Crazy Stix

$6.49

Grilled Chicken Salad

House, lite Italian, French, 1000 Island, ranch, blue cheese.

$5.99

Italian Salad

$3.99

Salads

Pasta

Baked Spaghetti

$5.99

Lasagna

$5.99

Prepared Fresh

With mozzarella, ricotta, Parmesan cheese and spices cheese calzone.

$5.99

Supreme Calzone

Pepperoni, mushroom, green pepper, onion.

$7.99

Calzones

New York Style Pizza

New York Style Pizza (Personal)

$4.69

New York Style Pizza (Large)

$12.99